Since I've lived in NYC my whole life and pretty much eat a sandwich every day for lunch, I thought I'd start reviewing some of the best I've eaten and new ones that I've tried. Feel free to argue any of the choices I've made or convince me of others. Follow me at leematthewgoldberg.com
Tuesday, March 20, 2012
TURKEY CLUB AT W.M. POLL
Purveyors of gourmet food since 1921, you'd be hard pressed to find better sandwiches on the Upper East Side. While the sandwiches don't come cheap at W.M. Poll, for $10 bucks you can get a solid turkey club. The turkey is fresh, not Boars Head or some other brand. The bacon hasn't been cooked hours ago, and the sandwich is big enough to cut in thirds. Besides an array of fresh dips and soups, the real star at W.M. Poll is their baked potato crisps that are made fresh every day. Try the rosemary, you won't be disappointed. Great place to get catering if you live nearby as well.
William Poll
1051 Lexington Ave
(between 74th St & 75th St)
New York, NY 10021
williampoll.com
Thursday, March 15, 2012
CHICKEN SCHNITZEL AT PICCOLO CAFE
An oasis amongst chain sandwich shops, the Piccolo Cafe in Midtown serves quality imported food from Italy. Walking inside is like entering a tiny sandwich shop in Florence. The chicken schnitzel with lettuce, marinated cherry tomatoes, and a paprika mayo is a fine example of what they do best. The focaccia bread is freshly baked, the chicken is breaded to a crisp, and the paprika mayo gives a sandwich a nice spicy kick that couples well with the saltiness of the marinated cherry tomatoes. For $10.00 you'd practically pay the same thing at Cosi, Pax, or Europa to get the same sandwich you've eaten a thousand times before. The cafe has sister locations in the Gramercy area and Hell's Kitchen as well. Check 'em out, but be forewarned because there's only a few seats and the place usually has a line out the door, so it's best to get your lunch there to go.
Piccolo Cafe
238 Mad. Ave.
212-447-4399
http://www.piccolocafe.us/
Tuesday, March 13, 2012
SALMON FOCCACIA At L'EXPRESS
Hands down, one of my favorite sandwiches in this city is the Salmon Foccacia at L'Express. Pretty much everything at L'Express is solid, but the salmon sandwich is the gold standard. The foccacia bread is fresh and sprinkled with rosemary. The salmon is perfectly cooked and sliced thin. But it's the added caramelized onions and a stellar lemon-caper mayo that truly makes the sandwich standout. The mayo should be bottled and sold on it's own: it's tangy and the capers give the sandwich a nice saltiness that counterbalances with the salmon. Served with killer shoestring fries and a petite salad for $12.95, it's a lunch that will keep you satisfied throughout the day.
L'EXPRESS
249 Park Avenue South
New York, NY 10003(212) 254-5858
lexpressnyc.com
lexpressnyc.com
Wednesday, March 7, 2012
HOT TURKEY FROM DEFONTES
I could literally just review the sandwiches from Defontes and be perfectly happy since they are that good. The hot turkey with swiss, fried eggplant, and natural jus is no exception. First of all, it is a monster of a sandwich. The turkey is piled high and the natural jus keeps it moist since there is nothing worse then dry turkey. Swiss always balances well with turkey, but it is the fried eggplant that is the real surprise and gives the sandwich a great, innovative crunch. I like mine with lettuce, tomato and mustard, only because I like mustard on everything. The sandwich tips the scales at $10.50, but if you consider it two sandwiches in one then it's a bargain. Their macaroni salad is pretty top-notch too as a side.
DEFONTES OF BROOKLYN
261 3rd Avenue New York, NY 10010
Tuesday, March 6, 2012
TUNA MELT AT KEKO CAFE
Eating at the Keko Cafe in midtown is like being transported to a long gone era in Europe. Time seems to slow down, as well. French music plays over the speakers. Only soccer is shown on the TVs. The menu is influenced by the Tunisian flavors in their crepes, pizzettas, and salads. The tuna melt is always a good choice, too. The baguette is fresh and the tuna has a perfect ratio of mayonnaise to fish along with a nicely melted swiss cheese. It is served with olives and pickles for $7.49. Smack in the middle of busy midtown, the Keko Cafe is a much-needed reprieve. And just like in Europe, the waitstaff won't be rushing you out of the door.
Keko Café
121 Madison Avenue (between 30th & 31st St.)
New York, NY 10016
121 Madison Avenue (between 30th & 31st St.)
New York, NY 10016
For Take-Out & Local Delivery orders
please call: (212) 685-4360
or fax: (212) 725-2874
please call: (212) 685-4360
or fax: (212) 725-2874
www.kekocafe.com
Thursday, March 1, 2012
GRILLED LEMON CHICKEN AT MILANT
Sometimes you want a one-of-a-kind sandwich and other times you're in a rush and just need a quick bite. The Grilled Lemon Chicken at Milant in Murray Hill is just that sandwich. The lemon sauce is tart and its served on crusty French bread with roasted peppers and a kick-ass honey mustard, definitely not the standard grilled chicken that you'd expect from an average deli. Milant has about thirty other choices of sandwiches with salad specials that include various dishes from crab cakes to grape leaves to smoked tuna and pasta all for under $7 bucks. All sandwiches come with the soup of the day for free so if you're looking for a cheap and good eatery in midtown, you could do a lot worse than Milant.
Milant Gourmet Deli
158 E. 39th St. (btw. Lex & 3rd)
212-682-0111
Wednesday, February 29, 2012
SUPER HEEBSTER AT RUSS AND DAUGHTERS
The Super Heebster at Russ and Daughters is a one-of-a-kind sandwich. Baked salmon salad and whitefish salad are mixed together and put on a bagel with horseradish dill cream cheese and wasabi flying fish roe. The two fishes work well together and taste less salty than whitefish salad on its own. The horseradish cream cheese contributes a nice punch along with tang of the wasabi roe, which adds an innovative texture to the sandwich. Russ and Daughters has been around since 1914 so they certainly know what they're doing. Pick up some of their fantastic smoked salmons and speciality smoked fish as well along with tasty desserts ranging from babkas to hand-dipped chocolates.
RUSS AND DAUGHTERS
179 East Houston Street
New York, NY 10002
T (212) 475.4880 or (800) RUSS-229
F (212) 475.0345
E-mail: info@russanddaughters.com
T (212) 475.4880 or (800) RUSS-229
F (212) 475.0345
E-mail: info@russanddaughters.com
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






